Technology -> Applications
RSS Feed:
|
By: Simon Holloway, Practice Leader - Process Management & RFID, Bloor Research Published: 3rd September 2007 Copyright Bloor Research © 2007 |
For those of you who are Microsoft watchers or users, you will know that Microsoft, this year, has been re-emphasizing its SharePoint portal server. One of the major UK SIs providing support for SharePoint is ICS Solutions, based in Basingstoke in Hampshire. ICS are some 20 years old and hold 5 Microsoft Gold competencies. ICS have not only helped other companies implement SharePoint but they have built a part of their business around a SharePoint Portal, called DreamTeam Portal, that provides a resourcing source for specialist Microsoft contractors. At the beginning of August 2007, I went to a public seminar held at Microsoft UK in Reading to hear ICS talk about a new business avenue—ICS acting as an ISV for a SharePoint based product called ShareWorkz.
ICS developed ShareWorkz based on their experience of working with SharePoint and their close relationship with analyst house Nielson Norman. The first version of ShareWorkz was released in April of 2006 with version 2.1 coming out in December of 2006, Version 3 was released in May 2007 and version 4.0 is expected at the end of the year. ICS have sunk some £1.3m in developing the product. ShareWorkz overcomes many of the problems associated with traditional portal developments. So what do you get out of the box?
Well firstly, ShareWorkz provides Instant Creator which produces a working solution in less than one hour. To prove this, Seb Matthews, ICS Business Development Manager for ShareWorkz, demonstrated to the audience the building of a simple internet in 14 minutes 51 seconds. Very impressive! Into an Excel spreadsheet, information about 6 people was added and a department structure was documented. By pressing a button the process was started of generating the XML to create the portal. The user interface has the look and feel of Microsoft Outlook/Microsoft CRM. ShareWorkz also implements the approach of Microsoft Rights Management Server, so that users are only shown what they can do. When you compare the capabilities of the Creator and the time taken to a cost of £150k over 14 months to produce an average successful internet portal, then this facility on its own looks really good value.
Efficient corporate communication can often represent a huge challenge. Most organisations recognise the importance of information sharing, but many lack the ability to make information easily available. ShareWorkz provides an Internet Content Publishing facility that allows an organisation to have a central point for the publishing and sharing of information. "RAD", described by Matthews as designed along the lines of Microsoft Word, provides a recognizable content capture/input mechanism. The product supports the use of user-definable and extendable template page layouts. There is also a workflow approval system based on Microsoft Workflow Framework. There are also tools that enable existing websites to be brought under ShareWorkz control.
Nielson Norman research has shown that internet users can waste an hour or so a day with poorly designed sites, because they can't find what they are looking for. ICS have therefore ensured that ShareWorkz provides a document storage and collaboration solution which has user-defined work spaces (called WorkzSpaces). The product supports not one tagging mechanism but two. The first is dynamic and is based on the business entities such as Customers, Projects and Suppliers. The second is a user-defined mechanism that allows personalised classifications to be built. There is a Google-like search engine called "Multi-Finder". In the demonstration, we were shown ShareWorkz working with Microsoft Dynamics CRM, where the latter set up the dynamic tagging. We were also shown ShareWorkz working with Microsoft Office in order to help users find the right place to store a document. One of the real good things that was demonstrated was that users can be prompted to tag documents when they go to store them.
Users can create their own collaboration sites by selecting from pre-built templates or by building their own. The default includes support for Brief (mission and objectives), calendar and tasks. There is a mini version of Multi-Finder available for searching. ShareWorkz shows its SPS inheritance with support for version handling, "Alert Me" and checkin/checkout facilities. There is an email link that is not switched on by default, which allows the user to send a link rather a document. (This is similar to the feature in Microsoft SharePoint). Automatic creation of system-wide project tags is supported. A feature that showed ICS' experience was the ability to send the project site to an extranet facility; even better was that the internet and extranet sites could be created and maintained at the same time! ShareWorkz uses Microsoft Exchange database search capability to pull emails into a project view. Microsoft Live Communication Server alert and presence capabilities have also been incorporated into ShareWorkz.
This is what Matthews called "the killer feature of ShareWorkz". Anyone who had gone through the process of creating extranet sites in SharePoint with all the necessary security knows how time-consuming the production of an extranet site can be. ShareWorkz provides the capability to create extranets for customers, partners and suppliers of an organisation in the same way as it supports intranets by using supplied templates or producing your own. This facility was demonstrated and Matthews was right—it certainly wowed the audience with its ease of use and facilities. One neat feature was the ability to expose shared data from internal databases.
This feature of ShareWorkz allows an organisation to view and interact with portal content by processes rather than by organisational structure. There is a library of more than 30 standard templates, such as holiday bookings and expense claims, provided. New processes can be created. For human workflow, ICS have worked with K2 (another Microsoft ISV and part of the Microsoft Business Process Alliance). There is a link to SAP either through ODBC or through the SAP SharePoint Server interface. This integration is supported for any product that has SharePoint Server integration facility defined.
The final facility! Unlike all the other features this is not quite out of the box as it does require some configuration work to make it work, but this should be expected as what works for one organisation won't for another. This is based around a concept called "SPOT", meaning a Single Point Of Truth. This is all about providing a single place within an internet where users can retrieve all the known information about a given business entity—customer, project or supplier. The customisation does not involve cutting of code. Like SharePoint, there is "MySite" facility. This facility was demonstrated using the link to Microsoft Dynamics CRM. The basic CRM features were shown running through the portal. The business entities that were dynamically tagged were content, invoice, order, document and email. All the documents associated with a particular order were shown, including associated emails. Any data stored within the portal can be associated with a SPOT.
ShareWorkz is interesting from a number of points of view.
Firstly we have a Systems Integrator (ICS Solutions) becoming a Software Vendor (ISV). This involves an organisation in a number of changes. Developing, selling and maintaining a software solution is not the same business model as selling consultancy and services. ICS Solutions have recognised the differences and to minimise the impact have set up a separate operating division to handle ShareWorkz. They have cunningly used the Microsoft server and user cals model for pricing ShareWorkz, which makes it easier to understand for Microsoft users. It also makes a good marketing ploy in comparing ShareWorkz to SharePoint Server! Pricing wise at £15k for the server, I feel that ICS have chosen well—it is certainly worth this for the features that you get. The User cals are discounted as the user number increase staring at from £70/user for 25–100 users and falling to £30/user for 1,000–3,000 users (under 25 users you pay no user cals only the server price). There is a compulsory annual maintenance charge of 20% of total server & user licenses cost. So, make sure, if you are considering this product, that you include this cost in your ROI calculations.
ICS Solutions have a good reputation in the Microsoft partner market for their knowledge and expertise in the development of portal solutions. All this knowledge and experience seems to have been input into the design of ShareWorkz, thus making it a product that, from the demonstration that I saw, look easy to use with some real practical wiz bangs that make it so much easier, quicker and less costly to get a credible quality internet and extranet solution up and running.
If you are looking at a portal solution or looking to change your current tools, I would recommend that you take a look at ICS Solutions ShareWorkz. It may not suit some people but it certainly will allow end users to maintain and even set up sites without heavy IT involvement.
Sorry, we are no longer accepting comments on this item. We suggest trying to contact the author directly.
20th September 2007: 'Matthias Sander' said:
I've heard good words about them. Some sources I've been talking with here and there were saying interesting things about this solution. I completely agree that the intranet site management of today is a challenging task. Another thing here that demands paying an extra attention if we are talking about the modern intranet site that quite frequently includes collaboration modules that use information that comes from the extranet is site security. And this could be even more daunting task. I agree with the term that the one of the major parameters that define the functionality, usefulness, and lastly, stability of a collaboration portal is its poor usability. That's because if it doesn't' t allow people to easily find the information it stores, quickly access to the piece of data the user wants to read or edit to, it puts the user into the confusion and hence it slowdowns the collaboration performance and productivity which are probably the corner stones that the whole idea of corporate portals lies upon. Sometimes it can be heard that the SharePoint management became a problem of that level of complexity that you have to be an expert in various areas involving IT technologies to effectively control it and govern the collaboration processes. And I can't say it's absolutely incorrect. Partially it's correct. And that's why. The modern technology that surrounds us everywhere evolved in a complex system. Even such a simple CE devices as a DVD-player in fact represents a very complex system that joins technologies emerged from mechanics, optics, physics of solids and semiconductors. But does it mean you need to be an expert in all of mentioned areas of physics to just play you movie or record an TV cast! God, no! You shouldn't. That's because the makers are doing their best to make devices easier to use and less burdening to the user. But what's missing with CE could be achieved with no problem with computer. What I love in Windows is the broad set of applications available to help the user work in various areas of businesses. The good example for this fact that you always have an option when working in Windows is the situation with managing security settings in SharePoint Server. The last edition of the SharePoint Server -Microsoft Office SharePoint Server 2007-has brought a huge list of enhancements aimed specifically to strengthen the site security and made the administration easier. But for such a complex system like the MOSS 2007 the rule works just fine - the defaults central administration console works well when managing a relatively small SharePoint farm but quickly becomes a challenge should you extend it by adding extranet sites and implementing cross-site security models. I wouldn't tell for the whole Universe but this is what I got myself when I tried to build up a extranet and mix up security that included both the users that work in our company and some of our customers that need access some documentation we expose on the extranet portal. I found out that even a simple copy operation while you are managing permission lists can drive you nut as it simply not convenient when managing this for multiple users or groups an this operation takes so much time that eventually you get that you are doing anything but security management. It's really hard to perform security management with the basic tools as you need to track each single step with your own. And even more to that, this all usually leads to security holes that appear because the complex farm structure simply leads to the corresponding complexity of controlling each security setting you've set or changed when making changes for this particular person. With my particular case I've chosen a standalone third-party SharePoint security management solution from Scriptlogic to configure security on out SharePoint farm. Their Security Explorer tool http://www.scriptlogic.com/products/security-explorer/
allows managing security for the whole SharePoint farm so that I can quickly switch from site to site to see the effect, compare differences in security and consolidate security settings. I like that idea they use here. They decided to not use basic web-based controls and implemented the tool with the standard GUI controls. The multitab GUI combined with the tree-like farm view does its job for 100%. But my favorite feature there is the search component. For example, it allows me to find all the objects that were given the Design permission. That's very useful when you need to clean traces after you provided someone with this right to perform the on-sites edits and want to revoke the permissions when the work is done.
The messages above were all contributed by IT-Director.com readers. Whilst we take care to remove any posts deemed inappropriate, we can take no responsibility for these comments. If you would like a comment removed please contact our editorial team.
Published by: IT Analysis Communications Ltd.
T: +44 (0)1908 880760 | F: +44 (0)1908 880761